WHY EGYPTS POWER HAS DIMMED
- Published:20 Aralık 2010, Pazartesi
- Updated:19 Ocak 2011, Çarşamba
At Bayoumys, a dingy, smoke-filled tea shop in downtown Cairo, Egyptian football fans groaned at the biased referee as they watched their national team lose 2-1 to the Gulf state of Qatar in a friendly last week. Once the television commentary had died away and people turned back to their backgammon games, some pondered an awkward question for Egypt, which prides itself on being the pre-eminent regional power. Why is it that gas-rich Qatar, a football minnow ranked 113 in the world, will host the 2022 World Cup the first in the Middle East while Egypt did not win a single vote when it bid for the Cup six years ago?
"Qatar does not have the history that Egypt has, but it has vision, money and the goal to be a leader among nations in the region," sighed the tea-shop proprietor Mr Bayoumy, reflecting on the past under former president Gamal Abdel Nasser. "Egypt had vision and resolve in Abdel Nasser's time and was even more independent than Qatar now, which has the largest U.S. military base in the Middle East. But this country has no vision any more, only officials who look after themselves."
Sipping his tea, Haj Masoud, 67, also lamented Egypt's lack of vitality. "Qatar is new at everything: diplomacy, history, wealth," he said. "Egypt has a long history in all of these areas but its people are too busy making ends meet."
Egypt may still be a football powerhouse — it captured the Cup of African Nations for the seventh time this year to bring its FIFA world ranking to 10 — but it can no longer claim automatic primacy as the foremost political, economic and cultural country in the Middle East. Non-Arab Turkey, Iran and Israel all arguably pack a bigger punch than Egypt these days, while oil giants Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates outmuscle it financially. Even an agile lightweight like Qatar can dodge into a diplomatic — and sporting — ring that Cairo once dominated.
"Egypt has virtually no influence as far as I can tell," says Beirut-based commentator Rami Khouri, who dates the decline in Cairo's clout to then-leader Anwar Sadat's 1977 peace-making trip to Jerusalem, when the Arab world pointedly declined to follow his lead. "Egypt used to be a creative, dynamic place, culturally and politically. Now it's very static and others have become more dynamic — the Syrians, Hezbollah, the Iranians, the Qataris. None of them has become the dominant actor, but they all play a role that used to be more monopolised by Egypt."
Egypt used to be the undisputed Arab power. In the 1950s and 60s, Nasser electrified Arabs with his defiance of colonial powers, enmity for Israel and heady brand of Arab nationalism and socialism. Western powers loathed him, just as today they revile Iranian leader Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and his "resistance" rhetoric.
Nasser projected Egyptian influence far and wide, even if he met ultimate disaster with defeat in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. His successor, Sadat, offered a bold alternative when he made Egypt the first Arab country to sign a peace treaty with Israel. Initially, the peace deal consolidated Egypt's role as the Middle East's most important interlocutor.
In the 21st century, though, Egypt's voice has faded. Today it is Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Syria which consult on how to keep Lebanon from slipping back into chaos. Iran is the outsider that carries most weight in Iraq's political struggles. Turkey has hosted indirect peace talks between Israel and Syria, linked up with Brazil to tackle Iran's nuclear row with the West and tried to reconcile rival Palestinian factions.
Even Qatar, home of al-Jazeera, the satellite television news station which helped destroy the grip of state media around the Arab world, has sought to mediate in conflicts in Yemen, Lebanon and Sudan's Darfur region — Egypt's own backyard.
Then there's the appeal of militant movements such as Lebanon's Hezbollah and the Palestinian Islamist Hamas, which can often resonate more than the policies of Egyptian and other Arab leaders who shelter under an unpopular U.S. military umbrella.
President Hosni Mubarak, 82, who has ruled Egypt for almost 30 years and may well stand for a sixth term next year, has preserved the peace treaty with Israel and stuck solidly in the U.S. camp. What he lacks, says Amr Hamzawy, an analyst at the Carnegie Endowment's Middle East Centre, is "the vision component. Mubarak is not a visionary leader and is too old to become one."
TURKEY'S RISING STAR
To get an idea of how far Egypt has slipped, it's instructive to look at Turkey, which in the past decade has transformed itself from a financial basket-case sitting on the periphery of Europe into a star emerging market and a rising regional power.
The International Monetary Fund expects Turkey's economy, buoyed by political stability and market-friendly reforms, to grow 7.8 percent in 2010, making it one of the world's best performers. That outshines Egypt, which is expected to grow by a still-sprightly 6 percent this fiscal year, after 5.1 percent last.
And it's not just the economy. A Brookings Institution poll this year found that Arabs admired Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan more than any other world leader. Under Erdogan's Islamist-rooted AK Party, in power since 2002, Turkey has fostered stronger trade and business links with Muslim countries. Its political and cultural profile has also risen in the Arab world, which it ruled for centuries as part of the Ottoman empire, sharing social and religious affinities.
In the past, Turkey — NATO's only Muslim member — avoided getting embroiled in the Middle Eastern quagmire. But in recent years it has used its growing influence and prestige to mediate in difficult conflicts. In a nod to growing Turkish clout, Barack Obama chose Turkey as the first Muslim country he visited as U.S. president — a trip seen as a diplomatic coup in Ankara, even though he later reached out to the Islamic world in a speech from Cairo.
Erdogan's condemnation of Israel after a deadly Israeli raid on a Turkish-led aid convoy bound for the Gaza Strip last May turned him into a hero in the Arab street — people in the Cairo slum of Manshiet Nasr hung Turkish flags from their windows.
Arab interest in Turkish culture — from TV soap operas, pop music and food to Turkey's rehabilitation of its Ottoman history — has also surged, fuelling an influx of Arab tourists. Istanbul, the old imperial capital, has become a popular wedding destination for Arabs.
"There are a number of areas in which you can say that Turkey has overtaken Egypt's place as a regional power," says Hugh Pope, an author of books on Turkey and a senior analyst at the International Crisis Group, a Brussels-based conflict resolution group. "In the 1950s and 1960s, Egypt was the voice that moved the Arab masses. Now the voice of Erdogan is the voice that moves the masses despite Turkey not being an Arab country."
Pope points out that Turkey has used its access to EU and U.S. markets and investments to liberalise and modernise, while many Arab economies, such as Egypt's, still wrestle with the legacy of state control.
"Turkey has a democratically elected government that is liberal, open-minded and Western-oriented, so its rise has not been threatening to the West … It's a model of benign Islam," says Hilal Khashan, a political science professor at the American University of Beirut. "The decline of Egypt's role is largely self-inflicted, as Mubarak's authority is not democratic."
But democracy is not the only way to gain power. Qatar and the United Arab Emirates, sleepy desert backwaters in the 1960s, have built shiny city-states in the Gulf, spending oil and gas revenue freely on infrastructure installed almost from scratch.
"The success of the UAE is less a success due to oil than a success of vision," said Jean-Francois Seznec, a Georgetown University professor. "Much of the credit … is down to two very dynamic ruling sheikhs, Zayed in Abu Dhabi and Rashid in Dubai. Under these rulers, the UAE roared into the modern world. They dragged their backward populations along for the ride."
With only six million people, most of them foreign workers, the UAE can react rapidly to changes and opportunities, he said. To achieve explosive economic growth, its leaders flattened bureaucracy, "did not impose taxes and in general provided an atmosphere of free trade".
Seznec said Gulf Arabs seem to pity Egypt. "Certainly its political influence has waned completely in any of the issues around, in favour of Saudi Arabia. From an economic standpoint, Egypt has even less influence."
Egyptians may have a solid national identity, compared to the Gulf statelets, but can only gasp at their spending power. Two-fifths of Egypt's people live in poverty, 30 percent are illiterate and food price inflation is 22 percent. "Qatar has money and knows how to spend it well, while our country also has money, but does not spend it right," said Farouk Magdy, a student at Cairo's Future University, paying rueful tribute to the "amazing" World Cup stadiums the Qataris are planning. "We could never have competed against their stuff."
THE U.S. CONNECTION
It hasn't helped that Egypt has bet everything on U.S.-led Middle East peace efforts, whose protracted failure may have proved a liability.
"Sadat, Mubarak and others promised that peace will not be a separate peace with Israel, but an Arab-Israeli peace, and also that peace will bring prosperity," says Gamal Soltan, of Cairo's Al-Ahram Centre for Political and Strategic Studies. Many Arabs now "perceive Egypt as a country just allying with the U.S. to protect the regime or implement U.S. policies or plots in the region."
Egypt receives about $1.3 billion (836 million pounds) a year in U.S. military aid, hosts one of the world's biggest American embassies and, along with Saudi Arabia, is Washington's most important Arab ally. In the Mubarak era, Cairo's main diplomatic role has been to facilitate Israeli-Palestinian peace talks and, in recent years, to try to reconcile feuding Palestinian groups Fatah and Hamas. Neither effort has borne fruit so far.
And while Washington and its Western allies appreciate Egypt's mediation efforts, some Arab leaders are privately scathing. Qatari Prime Minister Hamad bin Jassim Al Thani, quoted in a leaked U.S. cable made public by WikiLeaks, said Egypt had "no end-game", only a vested interest in dragging out Palestinian reconciliation talks as long as possible. "Serving as broker of the talks is Egypt's only business interest with the U.S.," the Qatari leader said.
Egypt's weaker role abroad may also be a result of its obsession with problems at home. Eliminating political challenges sucks up much energy, while corruption and an inert bureaucracy have hollowed out institutions and undercut economic reform efforts.
Mubarak, a former airforce commander, took over after Islamist militants assassinated Sadat in 1981 and has kept Egypt under emergency law ever since, stifling political freedom behind a facade of elections and multi-party democracy. On his watch, Egypt rebuilt ties with the Arab world in the 1980s, crushed an Islamist insurgency at home in the 1990s and accelerated liberal economic reforms from 2004, fuelling three years of 7 percent growth until a surge in global food prices and then a world economic slump braked the momentum.
Yet Egypt is burdened by the explosive expansion of its 79 million-strong population — set to double by 2043 if today's 2 percent annual growth rate persists. That population boom means that on a per-capita basis, Egypt's economy has also lagged behind peers such as Brazil and South Africa.
Ugly bouts of sectarian friction between majority Muslims and the Coptic Orthodox Christians who form at least a tenth of the population have eroded a long tradition of coexistence.
A more vibrant media scene now enlivens debate, but no major rival to Mubarak's National Democratic Party (NDP) has emerged, and the democratic deficit in a security-obsessed state risks tipping into bankruptcy.
The November 28 election produced a lopsided parliament almost devoid of opposition. Mubarak endorsed the vote, but even the United States said it was "dismayed" by reports of election-day interference and intimidation by security forces. Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood, a pan-Islamic movement and the main opposition group, has scant appetite for organising protests likely to invite a strong government crackdown, knowing it cannot count on support from Western countries wary of political Islam, according to Shahid Hamid, an analyst at the Brookings Doha Centre. "It is interested above all in survival and has little interest in provoking an all-out confrontation with the regime. They believe history is on their side and are willing to wait."
Most Egyptians did not bother to vote in last month's poll and many greeted the results with apathy and ingrained cynicism, not street protests. Stop people in the streets of Alexandria, Egypt's second city, and they readily share their frustrations.
"Elections mean nothing in Alexandria or in Egypt," complained Mohamed Abdel Fattah, a 68-year-old carpenter. "People are sick of politics. Each candidate is dirtier than the last, they buy votes with money — it's one big mafia."
Zinhar Rushdi, 52, an insurance employee in a suit, said MPs routinely ignore their constituents once they have secured the "personal gains and perks" that accrue from an assembly seat. "It's a patronage system," he explained, his soft voice almost drowned by the din of traffic. "Businessmen get immunity so they have cover to pursue everything they want."
CRISIS OF LEGITIMACY
Is there any hope of change? Mubarak's plans are uncertain. He has had health scares and is the second-oldest Arab leader after Saudi Arabia's ailing King Abdullah. If he runs in next year's presidential election, he will win. If he steps aside or fails to last his term, no one can be sure who will take over.
Despite official denials, many Egyptians believe Mubarak has groomed his businessman-politician son Gamal for the job, but few relish the notion of a dynastic handover in a republic.
"Mubarak's ideal of a strong but fair leader would seem to discount Gamal Mubarak to some degree, given Gamal's lack of military experience, and may explain Mubarak's hands-off approach to the succession question," mused U.S. ambassador Margaret Scobey in another leaked diplomatic cable. "Indeed, he seems to be trusting to God and the ubiquitous military and civilian security services to ensure an orderly transition," she wrote.
Lobna Mahmoud's grey Mercedes purrs past a security gate into the sudden calm of Palm Hills, where gardeners tend grassy terraces, sprinklers hiss over flower beds and birds sing. The villa she bought five years ago — prices have tripled since — is nearly complete, with its marble floors and pitched tile roof. It looks over a sprawling club with floodlit football pitch, tennis courts, Olympic-sized pool, cafes and restaurants.
"When I saw this place, it was like a dream," says Mahmoud, 45, a businesswoman who imports chemicals for paint factories. It may be only 30 km (19 miles) from downtown Cairo, but Palm Hills and many similar projects now ringing the city are a world away from the capital's relentless smog, grime and noise.
For most Egyptians, they might as well be on another planet.
In the gritty railway town of Dalgamoun, in the Nile Delta north of Cairo, black motor rickshaws jostle past plodding buffaloes in the mostly unpaved streets — a place where small factories and workshops coexist with slower rural rhythms. "Prices are rising like fire and I can't keep up, with the money I make and the big family I have," says 67-year-old Ali Abu Issa, serving tea in a truck-stop cafe on the outskirts of town. A grizzled ex-soldier who fought in Yemen and in the 1967 and 1973 wars against Israel, he has eight children.
"I call out to Mubarak to help us," he says, asserting that the president has a self-interested entourage which keeps him in the dark about the plight of the people. "Officials are corrupt and greedy. They take everything and leave us only scraps."
Rich-poor contrasts in Egypt seem starker than ever, but the government denies that only a privileged few have benefited from economic reform. Wealth is trickling down, insists Finance Minister Youssef Boutros-Ghali. "The quality of life of the average Egyptian has improved significantly, despite what you hear in the street."
Egypt could have done even better, he told Reuters, if reforms were not obstructed by bureaucracy and "people who don't believe foreigners should invest or buy land here — as if they were going to put it on their backs and walk off with it".
Magdy Rady, the cabinet spokesman, acknowledged that Egypt has lagged Turkey in attracting foreign direct investment in the past six years. Government figures show Egypt lured a total of $45 billion against Turkey's $81 billion in that period.
"The best we achieved was $13 billion," Rady says, adding that Turkey, which hit a high of $22 billion in 2007, had been spurred on by its ambitions to join the European Union.
Egypt can hardly aspire to EU membership, but, with no transition to more dynamic leadership in sight, hosting the Arab world's first World Cup might have been just the kind of project to galvanise the nation. With Qatar having grabbed those bragging rights, the football-crazy customers in Mr Bayoumy's tea-shop have a despondent analysis.
"Egypt's role is retreating in the region," said Magdy Saroh, a 43-year-old engineer, "because Egypt has stood still for 30 years while younger, energetic countries like Qatar that were not on the map have sprung up and are speeding ahead."
(Additional reporting by Marwa Awad, Edmund Blair, Yasmine Saleh, Patrick Werr and Dina Zayed in Cairo, Ibon Villelabeitia in Ankara and Martina Fuchs in Dubai; Editing by Simon Robinson and Sara Ledwith)
- Istanbul is breaking tourist records
District Culture and Tourism Director Bilgili: "In May, Istanbul broke a historical record by hosting over one million foreign visitors in a single month.
- Israeli tourists interest in Antalya peaks
The number of Israeli tourists to visit Antalya has increased by 133.3 percent. Tourists from the United States have also increased by 119 percent, while the number of tourists from Iran dropped by 63 percent.
- Turkeys tourism industry is hoping to reel in Arab tourists
While European tourists spend approximately 800 dollars a week in our country, Arab tourists spend four times that amount. The biggest issue in terms of drawing in tourists to the nations Eastern Black Sea region is the lack in accommodation.
- The Brits are coming to Dalaman
With the landing of the first flight to arrive to the ATM Dalaman Airport from Blackpool, England passengers were greeted with carnations and Turkish delight upon their arrival.
- Two million 451 thousand tourists in Turkey reported in April
The total sum of visiting tourists in Turkey reached 6 million 665 thousand 379 in the first four months of the year.
- Turkey becomes third in the world for most Blue Flag beaches
With 383 beaches, 21 marinas and 13 yachts accredited with Blue Flags, Turkey has now bumped France from its throne to become the third country, following Spain and Greece, to have the highest number of Blue Flags.
- Russians celebrate Victory Day in Alanya
Russians residing and vacationing in Antalya's Alanya district commemorated the 68th anniversary of May 9th Victory Day, which marks the Soviet Unions (USSR) victory over Nazi Germany, in a celebration held at the Goldcity Tourism Complex.
- Miniatürk hosted 6.5 million tourists
Miniatürk, a miniature park located on the shore of the Golden Horn in Istanbul which hosts 1/25th scale models of significant structures located throughout the Turkish and Ottoman geography from the past 3,000 years, is seeing an increase in interest every year since it was first opened a decade ago.
- We have spent 16.7 billion liras on trips
The number of trips taken in Turkey in 2012, decreased by 1.4 percent to reach a total 64,922,000.
- Turkey selected as Europes favorite spa destination
One of Indias most popular magazines, AsiaSpa India has awarded Turkey for being the most favorite spa destination in Europe.
- The air of early spring in tourism
The Association of Turkish Travel Agencies (TÜRSAB) President Ulusoy: "It is speculated that in 2013 the number of tourists will reach 33 million and tourism revenue will be approximately 31.5 billion dollars.
- A visa-free era with Kuwait
The Presidential Çankaya Palace hosted a signing ceremony for eight agreements with Kuwait on Monday.
- 250,000 foreign patients chose Turkey for treatment
The incentives implemented by the government have allowed the nations health tourism industry to soar: 250,000 patients from 107 different countries have chosen to receive treatment in Turkey.
- Turkey switches to e-Visas
Foreign nationals planning to visit Turkey will now be able to obtain their visas online through an electronic visa application system (e-Visa) launched by the Republic of Turkey on April 17.